Identifying and mitigating risks in the offshore windfarm value network: a summary of insights for the wind sector

report
Realizing the Dutch ambition of 21 GW of offshore wind capacity by 2032 depends on value networks that can deal effectively with known risks and hard-to-quantify uncertainties. A value network is the wider group of actors and their interactions, including flows of goods, infor- mation, finance and trust. For offshore wind, it extends beyond the component supply chain to include offshore contractors, infrastructure operators, electricity offtakers, governments and many more actors. With negligible critical raw material mining, limited manufacturing ca- pacity and a dominant position in offshore contracting, the Netherlands (and Europe) de- pends on a global market shaped by geopolitics. Around 4.7 GW is currently in operation, and 5.5 GW more is under construction, but the investment conditions needed to deliver the additional 11 GW are perceived risky. This report summarizes the full TNO report (TNO-2026-17867) for professionals in the off- shore wind sector and for Dutch policymakers. It sets out the risks that stakeholders perceive around offshore wind development and the actions that could mitigate them. The central finding is that risk is concentrated with a few actors, while the strategies to mitigate it are spread across the entire network. Offshore wind farm owners and component manu- facturers (original equipment manufacturers, OEMs) carry the largest and most varied risk ex- posure. And many strategies that could reduce those risks need to be implemented by other stakeholders in the value network. This mismatch between risk owners and mitigation strat- egy owners is the central obstacle to realize 21 GW in 2032 that this assessment identifies. The study applied a transparent and standardized five-step risk assessment approach: objec- tives, identification, analysis, evaluation and mitigation and sector stakeholder input and vali- dation was included throughout. More than 100 risk events were identified, grouped into 30 risk clusters and 13 of these were prioritized for mitigation (see figure below). Figure 1.1 The 13 risk clusters prioritized for mitigation (highlighted), plotted by expert-estimated likelihood and impact. Risks cascade downstream. Risks that start upstream – with raw material suppliers, component manufacturers and logis- tics – are passed down through contracts and end up in the wind farm owner's business case. This upstream-to-downstream cascade lies behind almost every prioritized risk in this TNO Public TNO-2026-18458 study, and it can make the business case look like a single, unmanageable problem. It is not. By breaking that problem down into separate risk topics (such as grid capacity, the value of wind power, tender design and lack of standardization), each risk can be assigned to its owner and matched with suitable mitigation strategies. Untangling these interconnected risks, rather than treating the business case as one unsolvable knot, is what makes the situation possible to mitigate. Risk tolerance levels differ per actor. No single risk tolerance threshold can be set for the whole value network: what one stake- holder sees as an acceptable risk, another may not. Risk prioritization is therefore subjective by design. Of the 13 prioritized risk clusters, only one (R035, the value at risk of a wind farm after the final investment decision) was judged urgent by all experts involved; the other 12 were judged urgent by one or more stakeholders. To address the prioritized risks, the study defined 21 mitigation strategies, spread across the value network. There is no shortage of strategies, but implementation stalls when no clear strategy owner can be identified, or when that owner is a different actor than the one exposed to the risk. Four priority strategies. Sector experts point to three out of 21 strategies that deserve priority attention: Transparent EU-level planning of offshore wind projects (M58), by EU and national governments. M58 stands out as the connecting strategy: a precondition for many of the other strategies to be effective. Maintaining the pace of public infrastructure investment (M84), given the long lead times, by national governments, port authorities and transmission system operators. Multi-actor coordination (M86), closely related to changing business models (M104). Together they underline the importance of new risk-sharing collaborations and contracts, taken up collectively by value network stakeholders, from OEMs via contractors to electricity offtakers. Act in parallel, despite imperfect information. Nearly all value network actors have mitigation strategies available to them. They need to act in parallel, not in sequence. Imperfect information is the normal state of value network risk management and should not hold actors back from proactive collaboration to reduce the un- certainties that slow the further industrialization of the wind sector. Expert judgement-based research and recommended iterations. The findings rest largely on expert judgement and should be read as indicative. A different group of experts, or a re-assessment at a different moment in time, is likely to produce a dif- ferent shortlist of risks. The five-step approach lends itself to repeated applications, combin- ing lighter interim rounds with periodic full updates. And qualitative insights can be combined with quantitative information over time. Future assessments also need knowledgeable and authoritative participants who together represent the full range of stakeholder perspectives and thereby contribute to the quality of the risk assessment.
TNO Identifier
1036192
Publisher
TNO
Collation
35 p.
Pages
33